Helping individuals, families, and businesses protect what matters most through personalized insurance solutions and trusted professional guidance.
Join thousands of Central Ohio families protected since 1957.
65+
Years in Business
A+
BBB Rating
9+
Coverage Types
100%
Independent Agency
Coverage for Every Stage of Life
As an independent agency, we represent dozens of top-rated carriers — so we find the right coverage at the right price for your unique situation.
Auto Insurance
Comprehensive coverage for cars, trucks, motorcycles, RVs, and classic vehicles. We compare rates across top carriers to find your best fit.
Homeowners Insurance
Protect your home and belongings from fire, theft, weather events, and liability — whether you own a starter home or custom build.
Renters Insurance
Affordable personal property and liability protection for renters. Covers theft, fire, and unexpected damages wherever you live.
Business Insurance
From home-based businesses to established companies — general liability, property, workers comp, and BOP policies tailored to your industry.
Commercial Coverage
Comprehensive commercial lines including commercial auto, professional liability, and umbrella policies for Ohio businesses of all sizes.
Life Insurance
Term, whole, and universal life insurance solutions to protect your family's financial future and provide lasting peace of mind.
Medicare Plans
Navigating Medicare can be complex. We help you compare Medicare Advantage, Supplement, and Part D plans to maximize your benefits.
Supplemental Coverage
Fill gaps in your existing coverage with dental, vision, critical illness, and accident supplemental insurance policies.
Umbrella Insurance
Extra liability protection above your auto and home policies — essential for families and business owners seeking comprehensive coverage.
Not sure what coverage you need?
Talk to an Expert — Free ConsultationWe Work for You,
Not the Insurance Company
Unlike captive agents tied to a single carrier, McCaffrey Insurance shops the market on your behalf — delivering better coverage, better rates, and better service.
Personalized Coverage Solutions
Every policy is matched to your specific life situation — not a one-size-fits-all product pushed by a single carrier.
Competitive Insurance Options
As an independent agency, we compare rates from dozens of top-rated carriers to deliver real value on every policy.
Fast Quote Assistance
Get a personalized quote quickly. We do the shopping so you don't have to — most quotes are ready within one business day.
Dedicated Customer Support
A real person answers when you call. Our team is here for policy questions, claims guidance, and coverage updates.
Experienced Insurance Professionals
Our licensed agents bring decades of combined experience in personal, commercial, and specialty insurance lines.
Trusted Protection Guidance
We work for you, not the insurance company. Our goal is to find the best protection for your budget and circumstances.
Protecting Central Ohio Since 1957
Three generations of McCaffrey family professionals have built lasting relationships with thousands of Ohio families and businesses. Our independence means we always put your interests first.
0+
Years Serving Ohio
0k+
Families Protected
0+
Carrier Partners
0%
Client Satisfaction
BBB Accredited
A+ Rating
Dublin, Ohio
Est. 1957
Real People. Real Protection.
Thousands of Central Ohio families and businesses trust McCaffrey Insurance to protect what matters most.
"McCaffrey Insurance has been handling our auto and home policies for over twelve years. Lynn and her team genuinely care about finding the right coverage — not just the easiest sale. When we had a claim, they walked us through every step."
Ben Powers
Dublin, OH Homeowner
"As a family with multiple properties and vehicles, having one trusted agency manage everything is invaluable. McCaffrey Insurance has consistently found us better rates than we had before, while actually improving our coverage. Highly recommend."
Dr. G Jerry & Lisa Trotti
Central Ohio Residents
"I switched my business and personal insurance to McCaffrey three years ago. The difference is night and day. They explained exactly what I was getting and why — no pressure, no confusing jargon. Real professionals who genuinely look out for you."
Chris Conrad
Small Business Owner, Dublin OH
"As a first-time homeowner, I had no idea what insurance I needed. The McCaffrey team took the time to explain all my options and found me a comprehensive bundle that was actually affordable. I felt like a priority, not just a policy number."
Sarah Whitfield
New Homeowner, Powell OH
"Getting commercial coverage as a contractor can be a nightmare. McCaffrey made it simple, found me competitive rates, and made sure I had the right liability limits for my contracts. They've saved me both time and money every year."
Michael Harrington
Contractor, Columbus OH
"Navigating Medicare was overwhelming until I called McCaffrey Insurance. They compared all my options patiently and found a plan that covered everything I needed. Truly exceptional, personalized service — just like it used to be."
Patricia Morales
Retired, Dublin OH
BBB Accredited Business
A+ Rating — Highest Possible
Dublin Chamber of Commerce
Active Member · Dublin, Ohio
A Family Agency
Serving Ohio Families
Founded in 1957, McCaffrey Insurance Agency has been a trusted name in Central Ohio for over six decades. What started as a community-focused agency has grown into a multi-generational family business — but our core values have never changed.
As an independent agency, we are not tied to any single insurance company. That independence is your advantage: we compare policies from dozens of top-rated carriers to find coverage that genuinely fits your life, your budget, and your long-term goals.
"We do not work for an insurance company. We work for you."
Lynn McCaffrey
Principal Agent & Owner
James McCaffrey
Senior Insurance Advisor
BBB A+ Rating
Accredited Business
Dublin Chamber
Active Member
Request Your Free Quote
Fill out the form below and a McCaffrey Insurance professional will contact you within one business day — no obligation, no pressure.
Contact Information
McCaffrey Insurance Agency, LLC
5114 Blazer Pkwy
Dublin, OH 43017